| Â | | | | Certificate are all made with mesh that |
| | | | already conforms to official standards. |
| Sieving in its most elemental definition is | | | | However, there are three lower grade levels |
| the separation of fine material from coarse | | | | of sieve mesh available when tolerance levels |
| material by means of a meshed or perforated | | | | are not as stringent. |
| surface. The technique was used as far back | | | | |
| as the early Egyptian days as a way to size | | | | The first is Market Grade. These sieves have |
| grains. These early sieves were made of woven | | | | a weave that uses a larger diameter wire |
| reeds and grasses. Today the sieve test is | | | | resulting in a high strength square-mesh |
| the technique used most often for analyzing | | | | cloth suitable for general purpose screening. |
| particle-size distribution. | | | | There are no official standards for Market |
| | | | Grade test sieves. The second, Mill Grade, is |
| Although at first look the sieving process | | | | a class of woven mesh using smaller wire, |
| appears to be elementary, in practice, there | | | | which results in larger open areas in the |
| is a science and art involved in producing | | | | screen mesh. There is also a Twill Weave in |
| reliable and consistent results. In order to | | | | which the weft and warp wires alternatively |
| better understand sieving, there are several | | | | run over and under two wires rater than over |
| areas of sieve specifications that should to | | | | and under alternate wires as in standard |
| be explained, including: | | | | mesh. As none of these have official |
| | | | standards against which to measure the |
| 1. What Are Test Sieves? | | | | expected performance, none of these are |
| | | | provided with a mesh certificate. |
| Test sieves are measuring devices used to | | | | |
| determine the size and size distribution of | | | | 5. Sieve Calibration |
| particles in a material sample using wire | | | | |
| mesh of different openings to separate | | | | Quality control of the sieving process is |
| particles of different sizes. | | | | essential, and for people involved in |
| | | | material processing and particle |
| Test sieves usually consist of wire mesh held | | | | characterization, sieve calibration can be a |
| in a frame. In most laboratory applications | | | | confusing topic. It is beneficial to |
| the frame is round and is made from stainless | | | | understand what sieve calibration is, why a |
| steel or brass. The standard frame sizes are | | | | working sieve should be calibrated, and how |
| three, six, eight, ten, or twelve inch | | | | to calibrate a sieve. |
| diameters and metric equivalents. The woven | | | | |
| mesh can be made of stainless steel, brass, | | | | A. What Is Sieve Calibration? |
| or bronze. For most applications stainless | | | | |
| steel is the most common material used. | | | | Sieve calibration is the process of checking |
| | | | a working sieve's performance. (A working |
| 2. What Are the Limitations of the Test Sieve | | | | sieve is a test sieve that is used regularly |
| Procedure? | | | | to perform a particle size analysis.) |
| | | | |
| The main limitation with the construction of | | | | B. Why Calibrate a Working Sieve? |
| test sieves is the inherent nature of a woven | | | | |
| product including control of sag when mounted | | | | Since working sieves are used daily for |
| and the uniformity of construction of the | | | | tests, they are also cleaned regularly. |
| holding frame. It is also essential to | | | | Although frequent use in itself can cause |
| maintain consistent sizing across all the | | | | changes in mesh openings, much of the damage |
| openings in a piece of mesh. | | | | sustained to working sieves occurs during |
| | | | cleaning. Often, the operator hurries to |
| Because of the inherent variations of | | | | clear the mesh of residual particles by |
| openings in any woven product there are | | | | strongly tapping the frame. This tapping can |
| limitations to the degree of uniformity | | | | distort the mesh. Operators also use brushes |
| achieved in the opening size across the mesh | | | | to remove residual particles after a test. |
| in a sieve. This results in a practical limit | | | | This process often distorts sections of the |
| to the range of openings and to the precision | | | | sieve mesh. These alterations of the sieve |
| of results from a specific sieve. | | | | will change the results obtained in |
| | | | subsequent tests, hence the need for |
| The sieve test requires particles to pass | | | | calibration. |
| through the sieve mesh. The practical limit | | | | |
| for using a test sieve procedure is a | | | | Excessive damage such as tears or large |
| particle size of 20? (microns). | | | | distortions of the mesh weave can be detected |
| | | | by visual inspection. Damaged sieves can be |
| 3. What Are the Test Sieve Standards? | | | | taken out of service when the damage is |
| | | | observed. When the change is small, visual |
| The first sieve testing standards were | | | | observation may not detect a variation in the |
| developed by W.S. Tyler Company before 1920. | | | | test results attributable to the sieve's |
| This original work predated any published | | | | change. A way to determine if changes have |
| activity by the standards organizations and | | | | occurred is to compare the sieve's |
| the Tyler designation is the de facto | | | | performance against a known standard. This is |
| standard in many industries. In 1925, ASTM | | | | sieve calibration. |
| International prepared the official standard | | | | |
| for Test Sieve Size, Test Sieve Construction, | | | | In addition, in operations with tight |
| and Test Sieve Mesh in the United States. | | | | particle size specifications, calibration of |
| European Standards were developed by a German | | | | new test sieves is performed to establish a |
| university group in 1977 and are known by the | | | | performance baseline for the sieve. |
| designation DIN 4188. These were followed by | | | | |
| British Standards (BS 410). The International | | | | C. How is a Test Sieve Calibrated? |
| Standards (ISO 565) were developed by the | | | | |
| International Standards Organization in | | | | The base point of a sieve calibration process |
| Europe. This was designed to be the universal | | | | is the use of a fixed standard and there are |
| international standard. However, in practice, | | | | a number of approaches used. The most common |
| all of the standards are in operation. | | | | is the use of a master stack of sieves, a |
| | | | master sample, or calibration spheres or |
| Sieve testing standards relate to the | | | | beads. |
| construction of the sieve frame and mesh | | | | |
| mounting as well as the tolerances allowed in | | | | A master stack of sieves includes one of each |
| the variability of mesh openings. Basic | | | | of the sieves used in the processes. A master |
| principles are common to all of the standards | | | | stack should consist of Mesh-Certified |
| and variations in terminology and in details | | | | sieves. In the event of tight tolerances for |
| are small. These small differences, however, | | | | the sieve tests it is recommended that |
| can often lead to confusion. The following is | | | | Mid-Point sieves be used. The following steps |
| a synopsis of the principles behind these | | | | are used for this method: |
| standards. | | | | |
| | | | 1. Prepare two samples of the material |
| Test sieve frame standards include the | | | | selected for the calibrations process |
| following: | | | | |
| | | | 2. Place the master stack of sieves on a |
| 1. Rigid construction | | | | sieve shaker |
| | | | |
| 2. Cloth (mesh) mounted without distortion, | | | | 3. Load one of the samples into the top sieve |
| looseness, or waviness | | | | |
| | | | 4. Run on a sieve shaker for the |
| 3. Joint between mesh and frame to be filled | | | | predetermined time |
| or constructed so that particles will not be | | | | |
| trapped | | | | 5. Prepare a percent-retained analysis of the |
| | | | result |
| 4. Frame will be of non-corrosive material | | | | |
| and seamless | | | | 6. Place the stack of working sieves (sieves |
| | | | with sizes to match master stack) |
| 5. Bottom of the frame sized to easily slide | | | | |
| into the top of same sized sieve, thus | | | | 7. Repeat steps three through five for the |
| enabling stacking | | | | second sample of the material |
| | | | |
| 6. Cloth opening to be a minimum of 0.5 | | | | 8. Compare the results of the two analyses |
| inches less than nominal diameter | | | | |
| | | | 9. Check variance from the master stack |
| The wire cloth (mesh) standards include the | | | | against acceptable tolerances |
| following list of nominal size openings in | | | | |
| inches, millimeters (microns), and sieve | | | | 10. Replace the working sieves that are out |
| number. The following specific dimensional | | | | of tolerance |
| examples come from the ASTM E11 Standard: | | | | |
| | | | Some users only calibrate one sieve at a time |
| 1. Permissible variation of average openings | | | | and compare it to one sieve from the master |
| (depending on opening size and ranges from | | | | set. This procedure can be done before |
| ± 2.9% of nominal size for 125 mm | | | | putting new working sieves in service. |
| mesh to ± 15% for 20? mesh) | | | | |
| | | | In some processes master samples are |
| 2. Not more than 5 % of the openings can | | | | maintained of all material that is subject to |
| exceed 1.04 times the nominal size for 125 mm | | | | sieve testing. The results expected from |
| mesh to 1.45 times the nominal opening for | | | | working sieves were established through the |
| 20? mesh | | | | use of a master sieve stack or other |
| | | | calibration techniques. In this method a |
| 3. Maximum individual opening (for any | | | | sample from the master is used and the |
| opening) ranges from 1.0472 times the nominal | | | | following steps are taken: |
| size for 125 mm mesh to 1.75 times the normal | | | | |
| mesh for 20? mesh | | | | 1. Place the stack of working sieves to be |
| | | | checked on a sieve shaker |
| 4. Wire diameters are specified and range | | | | |
| from 8 mm for 125 mm mesh to 0.020 | | | | 2. Load the selected sample from the master |
| millimeters for 20? mesh | | | | sample into the top sieve |
| | | | |
| More recently, methods based on laser and | | | | 3. Run the sieve shaker for the predetermined |
| energy technologies, sedimentation | | | | time |
| techniques, image analysis, and | | | | |
| centrifuge-type methods have gained | | | | 4. Prepare a percent retained analysis of the |
| acceptance. However, procedures using test | | | | result |
| sieves are still widely used. The sieve-test | | | | |
| result remains the basis or standard against | | | | 5. Compare the results to acceptable |
| which newer techniques are checked. In | | | | tolerances for the sieves in this stack |
| addition, the equipment cost for the test | | | | |
| sieve procedure is significantly lower than | | | | 6. Replace the working sieves that are out of |
| the capital investment needed for newer | | | | tolerance |
| methods. | | | | |
| | | | The used sample may be returned to the |
| 4. What Are Sieve Certifications? | | | | original master sample. Depending on the type |
| | | | of material, deterioration may occur during |
| Sieve certifications are statements that a | | | | the sieve test. Where this occurs the test |
| test sieve meets or exceeds published | | | | sample is discarded after use. |
| criteria. It is an assurance that a new sieve | | | | |
| will perform in a predictable way. The closer | | | | As with the use of a master stack, some users |
| the tolerance required in a manufacturing | | | | only calibrate one sieve at a time and |
| process, the higher the level of | | | | compare it to a performance tolerance chart |
| certification needed. Similarly, a master set | | | | for that sieve size. This procedure can also |
| of test sieves against which working sieves | | | | be used for new working sieves before putting |
| (sieves in everyday use) are checked for wear | | | | them into service. |
| and predicted performance need a high level | | | | |
| of certification. When test sieves are part | | | | Calibration spheres, in sizes for each of the |
| of a process that is required to meet | | | | sieves to be calibrated, are used to |
| traceability prerequisites, such as a | | | | determine the actual results obtained by each |
| specific ISO level, a certification will | | | | sieve tested. This method is simple and gives |
| document the needed traceability. | | | | a precise result on the mean aperture size. |
| | | | The result is traceable to NIST and NPL |
| Many sieve manufacturers provide a | | | | standards. It is a good check for standards |
| certificate which states that the sieve was | | | | reporting and for setting internal standards. |
| manufactured in conformance with a specific | | | | The procedure for this calibration is as |
| standard (e.g., ASTM, ISO). This | | | | follows: |
| Manufacturing Conformance Certificate does | | | | |
| not reference nor does it certify conformance | | | | 1. Select the sieve to be calibrated |
| of the mesh. Most manufacturers supplying a | | | | |
| Conformance Certificate will analyze the mesh | | | | 2. Empty the contents of the bottle |
| and provide a mesh certification for an extra | | | | containing the appropriate standard onto the |
| charge. | | | | sieve |
| | | | |
| A Mesh-Certified Sieve will be provided with | | | | 3. Shake evenly over the surface for one |
| a certificate that states the sieve was | | | | minute |
| manufactured in accordance with a specified | | | | |
| standard and it was submitted for laboratory | | | | 4. Calculate the percent passing through and |
| analysis and is certified to conform to that | | | | read the mean aperture for a calibration |
| specific specification/standard (e.g., ASTM, | | | | graph |
| ISO). | | | | |
| | | | The method specified by ASTM is to optically |
| There is a third level of tolerance which | | | | inspect a sample of the openings, measure the |
| certifies that the manufacturing standard is | | | | apertures and the wire, and compare the |
| met and that the mesh was submitted for | | | | results with the ASTM E11 Standard. |
| laboratory analysis. It also certifies that | | | | Traditionally, this has been accomplished |
| its openings fall in the middle of the | | | | visually using a microscope. However, there |
| specific standard/specification (e.g., ASTM, | | | | are new computer-based image analysis systems |
| ISO). This is effectively a 30% better | | | | that are beginning to have limited use for |
| tolerance than the mesh of a Fully-Certified | | | | sieve calibration. |
| sieve. This is known as a Mid-Point Sieve. | | | | |
| These three levels of sieve certification | | | | 6. Summary |
| enable the comparability of performance of | | | | |
| one sieve to another of the same size. | | | | Sieves have a long history as the base for |
| | | | measuring and analyzing particle size in |
| Until the development of the Mid-Point Sieve, | | | | material. In spite of the advent of new |
| high levels of comparability were achieved by | | | | technology-based methods, procedures based on |
| providing sieves that were optically matched | | | | sieves continue to be the main basis for |
| to a user's standard sieve. A time consuming | | | | particle size determination. In order to |
| and costly procedure was needed to accomplish | | | | produce reliable and consistent results, it |
| this level of comparability and the results | | | | is evident that sieving requires an |
| were not significantly better than those | | | | understanding of not just one, but a |
| achieved by using Mid-Point Sieves. | | | | combination of integral factors such as test |
| | | | sieves, limitations of the test sieve |
| Mesh-Certified Sieves, Mid-Point Sieves, and | | | | procedure, test sieve standards, sieve |
| sieves carrying the Manufacturing Conformance | | | | certifications, and sieve calibration. |