| Alliances frequently result in mergers and/or | | | | Products, Fire and Security Services, Flow |
| acquisitions. Partnering relationships, such | | | | Control, and Electrical and Electronic |
| as joint ventures or strategic alliances, can | | | | Components. Through its corporate strategies |
| sometimes lead to a merger or acquisition | | | | of high-value production, decentralized |
| situation. After companies work together for | | | | operations, growth through synergistic and |
| a period of time and get to know one | | | | strategic acquisitions, and expansion through |
| another's strengths, weaknesses, and | | | | product/market globalization, Tyco has |
| synergistic possibilities, new relationship | | | | evolved. From Tyco's beginnings in 1960 as a |
| opportunities become apparent. One could | | | | privately held research laboratory, it has |
| argue that a joint venture or strategic | | | | transformed into today's multinational |
| alliance is simply the getting to know each | | | | industrial corporation that is listed on the |
| other part of a courtship between companies | | | | New York Stock Exchange. The Company operates |
| and that the real marriage does not occur | | | | in more than 80 countries around the world |
| until the relationship has been consummated | | | | and had fiscal 1999 revenues in excess of $22 |
| by a merger or acquisition. | | | | billion. |
| | | | |
| To make the point, Dan McQueen, president, at | | | | In the mid-1980s, Tyco returned its focus to |
| Fluid Components International (FCI) built a | | | | sharply accelerating growth. During this |
| Partnering relationship with Vortab, a small | | | | period, it reorganized its subsidiaries into |
| technology company. Vortab produced static | | | | the current business segments listed above. |
| mixers, a technology suitable for flow | | | | The Company's name was changed from Tyco |
| conditioning that complemented FCI's product | | | | Laboratories, Inc. to Tyco International Ltd. |
| offering. While Vortab also had three other | | | | in 1993, to reflect Tyco's global operations |
| distribution partners in addition to FCI, | | | | more accurately. Furthermore, it became, and |
| FCI's volume with Vortab continued to grow to | | | | remains, Tyco's policy to focus on adding |
| the point that Vortab's technology became an | | | | high-quality, cost-competitive, low-tech |
| important part of FCI's total sales volume. | | | | industrial/commercial products to its product |
| After about three years into the | | | | lines that can be marketed globally. |
| relationship, FCI acquired Vortab. | | | | |
| | | | In addition, the Company adopted synergistic |
| Because of the close relationship between | | | | and strategic acquisition guidelines that |
| Vortab and FCI, when the Vortab was put up | | | | established three base-line standards for |
| for sale McQueen knew its true value. | | | | potential acquisitions, including: |
| Resulting from his knowledge, FCI was able to | | | | |
| purchase Vortab at a much more realistic | | | | 1. A company to be acquired must be in a |
| price than Vortab's asking price. The Vortab | | | | business related to one of Tyco's four |
| technology integrated well with FCI's core | | | | business segments. |
| competency technology and today FCI also | | | | |
| distributes Vortab through some of its | | | | 2. A company to be acquired must be able to |
| non-direct competitors. | | | | expand the product line and/or improve |
| | | | product distribution in at least one of |
| The following list demonstrates some of the | | | | Tyco's business segments. |
| specific values created or developed from the | | | | |
| various organizational blending methods: | | | | 3. A company to be acquired that will |
| | | | introduce a new product or product line must |
| · Operational resource sharing | | | | be using a manufacturing and/or processing |
| | | | technology already familiar to one of Tyco's |
| · Functional skill transfer | | | | business segments. |
| | | | |
| · Management skill transfer | | | | Tyco also developed a highly disciplined |
| | | | approach to acquisitions based on three key |
| · Leverage (economies of scale) | | | | criteria that the Company continues to use |
| | | | today to gauge potential acquisitions: |
| · Capability increases | | | | |
| | | | 1. Post-acquisition results will have an |
| Mergers | | | | immediate positive impact on earnings; |
| | | | |
| Mergers occur when two or more organizations | | | | 2. Opportunities to enhance operating profits |
| come together to blend or link their | | | | must be substantial; |
| strengths. Also in the deal is a blending of | | | | |
| their weaknesses. The hopeful result is a new | | | | 3. All acquisitions must be non-dilutive to |
| more powerful organization that can better | | | | shareholders. |
| produce goods and services, access markets, | | | | |
| and deliver the highest quality customer | | | | Using its synergistic/strategic guidelines to |
| service. Mergers offer promise for | | | | acquisitions, Tyco succeeded in significantly |
| synergistic possibilities. This is achieved | | | | improving the Company's positions in each of |
| by the blending of cultures and retaining the | | | | its four business segments. During the period |
| core strengths of each. In this scenario, a | | | | from 1986 to the present, a number of smaller |
| new and different organization generally | | | | acquisitions were made to strengthen specific |
| emerges. The goal is a sharing of power, but | | | | product lines or enhance the Company's |
| usually the strongest rise to the top | | | | competitive position in the various segments. |
| leadership. | | | | The major acquisitions were: |
| | | | |
| Exxon - Mobil | | | | · 1986 - Grinnell Corporation, |
| | | | manufacturers and distributors of industrial |
| The Federal Trade Commission gave Exxon and | | | | construction products (which with Grinnell |
| Mobil the green light On November 30, 1999 | | | | Fire Protection Systems acquired by Tyco in |
| for their $80 billion merger. The next day | | | | the 1970s brought back together the two |
| the transaction was completed. The merged | | | | divisions of the original Grinnell |
| organization officially became Exxon Mobil | | | | Corporation under the Tyco umbrella). |
| Corp. The merger actually brings "the | | | | |
| companies back to their roots when they were | | | | · 1988 - Allied Tube and Conduit, |
| part of John Rockefeller's Standard Oil | | | | manufacturers of steel pipe and related |
| empire. That company was the largest oil firm | | | | tubular products. |
| in the world before it was busted up by the | | | | |
| government in 1911." | | | | · 1989 - Mueller Company, manufacturers of |
| | | | water and gas flow control products. |
| At the 1998 announcement of their intention | | | | |
| to merge, Mobil chairman, Lucio Noto made a | | | | · 1991 - Wormald International Limited, |
| comment about the need to merge. He said, | | | | manufacturers, contractors and suppliers of |
| "Today's announcement combination does not | | | | fire protection systems and products. |
| mean rhat we could not survive on our own. | | | | |
| This is not a combination based on | | | | · 1992 - Neotecha, manufacturers of |
| desperation, it's one based on opportunity. | | | | Teflon-lined butterfly/ball valves and |
| But we need to face some facts. The world has | | | | sampling devices. |
| changed. The easy things are behind us. The | | | | |
| easy oil, the easy cost savings, they're | | | | · 1993 - Hindle/Winn, manufacturers of |
| done. Both organizations have pursued | | | | high performance butterfly/ball valves. |
| internal efficiencies to the extent that they | | | | |
| could." | | | | · 1994 - Classic Medical, Uni-Patch and |
| | | | Promeon, three separate companies each |
| While part of the deal was the selling of a | | | | involved in providing a disposable medical |
| Northern California refinery and almost 2,500 | | | | product or supplementary products. |
| gas station locations, the divestiture | | | | |
| represents only a fraction of their combined | | | | · Preferred Pipe, manufacturers of forged |
| $138 billion in assets. Lee Raymond, Exxon | | | | steel products. |
| chairman, now chairman and chief executive of | | | | |
| the merged company said, "The merger will | | | | · Kendall International Co., among the |
| allow Exxon Mobil to compete more effectively | | | | world's largest manufacturers and |
| with recently combined multinational oil | | | | distributors of disposable medical supplies, |
| companies and the large state-owned oil | | | | wound care dressings, bandaging, elastic |
| companies that are rapidly expanding outside | | | | support and other vascular therapy |
| their home areas." | | | | compression products. |
| | | | |
| Exxon Mobil is now like a small oil-rich | | | | · 1995 - Tectron Tube, manufacturers of |
| nation. They have almost 21 billion barrels | | | | pipe and tubular products. |
| of oil and gas reserves on hand, enough to | | | | |
| satisfy the world's entire energy needs for | | | | · Unistrut, manufacturers of metal framing |
| more than a year. Yet, there is still the | | | | products and services. |
| opportunity to cut costs. The companies | | | | |
| expect their merger's economies of scale to | | | | · Earth Technology Corporation, an |
| cut about $2.8 billion in costs in the near | | | | environmental consulting firm specializing in |
| term. They also plan to cut about 9,000 jobs | | | | the design of water and wastewater treatment |
| out of the 123,000 worldwide. | | | | facilities. |
| | | | |
| AOL - Time Warner | | | | · 1996 -Professional Medical Products, |
| | | | Inc., makers of adult incontinence products |
| On January 10, 2000, Steve Case, chairman and | | | | and other disposable medical products. |
| chief executive of America Online (AOL), sent | | | | |
| an e-letter to his 20 million members. He | | | | · Thorn Security, manufacturer, installer |
| said, "Less than two weeks ago, people all | | | | and servicer of fire and security systems |
| over the world came together in a global | | | | worldwide. |
| celebration of the new century, and the new | | | | |
| millennium. As I said in my first Community | | | | · Carlisle, a leading manufacturer of |
| Update of the 21st Century, all of us at AOL | | | | specialty packaging materials and garment |
| are extremely excited by the challenges and | | | | hangers. |
| prospects of this new era, a time we think of | | | | |
| as the Internet Century. | | | | · Watts Waterworks Businesses, |
| | | | manufacturers of valves, hydrants, and |
| I believe we have only just begun to see | | | | fittings used primarily in water utility, |
| clearly how the interactive medium will | | | | wastewater treatment and power generation |
| transform our economy, our society, and our | | | | markets. |
| lives. And we are determined to lead the way | | | | |
| at AOL, as we have for 15 years-by bringing | | | | · Sempell, a manufacturing and servicer of |
| more people into the world of interactive | | | | specialty valves used in industrial and power |
| services, and making the online experience an | | | | generation applications. |
| even more valuable part of our members' | | | | |
| lives. | | | | · ElectroStar, a leading manufacturer of |
| | | | complex printed circuit boards. |
| That is why I am so pleased to tell you about | | | | |
| an exciting major development at AOL. Today, | | | | · 1997 - American Pipe & Tube, a |
| America Online and Time Warner agreed to join | | | | manufacturer of steel pipe, tubing for the |
| forces, creating the world's first media and | | | | fire protection, fence markets and steel |
| communications company for the Internet | | | | studs/trusses for the residential and |
| Century. The new company, to be created by | | | | commercial construction markets. |
| the end of this year, will be called AOL Time | | | | |
| Warner, and we believe that it will quite | | | | · Submarine Systems Inc., the leader in |
| literally change the landscape of media and | | | | the design, development, manufacture, |
| communications in the new millennium." | | | | installation, supply and maintenance of |
| | | | undersea fiber optic telecommunications cable |
| The next day newspaper headlines read, | | | | systems. |
| "America Online, Time Warner Propose | | | | |
| $163-Billion Merger." The Los Angeles Times | | | | · ADT, a leading installer and servicer of |
| said, "In an audacious deal bringing together | | | | electronic security systems. |
| traditional entertainment and the new world | | | | |
| of the Internet, America Online and Time | | | | · Keystone, a leading designer and |
| Warner Inc. on Monday announced they will | | | | manufacturer of industrial valves, actuators |
| merge in the largest business transaction in | | | | and accessories marketed worldwide. |
| history." | | | | |
| | | | · INBRAND, a manufacturer and distributor |
| The story later revealed the value | | | | of adult incontinence products. |
| comparisons of the companies. While AOL earns | | | | |
| less than Time Warner, the stock market | | | | · Sherwood Davis & Geck, a manufacturer |
| thinks AOL's shares are worth more. "America | | | | and distributor of disposable medical |
| Online is valued by the stock market at | | | | products. |
| nearly twice Time Warner-$173 billion, | | | | |
| compared with $101 billion as of Friday's [1 | | | | L. Dennis Kozlowski, chairman of the board |
| 7/00] market close-even though it has | | | | and CEO said, "Tyco is successful because it |
| one-third Time Warner's annual revenues." | | | | adheres to basic strategies such as being a |
| The article also stated "AOL earned $762 | | | | high-value producer, keeping our business |
| million on $4.8 billion in sales in the year | | | | simple and close to our markets and |
| ended Sept. 30 [1999]." AOL chairman, Case | | | | customers, empowering our employees for |
| wants to move fast. The Times article stated, | | | | greater achievements, while growing |
| "Case said the two chairman began discussing | | | | internally and through acquisitions." Good |
| a combination this fall [1999], he has tried | | | | ideas, but too bad about Kozlowski--I guess |
| to impress upon Levin [Gerald Levin, chairman | | | | one should be careful on how much is spent on |
| at Time Warner] the need to operate the new | | | | a birthday party? |
| company at Internet speeds." (We all know the | | | | |
| rest of the story...nothing is forever.) | | | | Irving Gutin, senior vice president at Tyco |
| | | | has worldwide responsibilities for corporate |
| The prophets of gloom are always ready to | | | | development and 30 years of M&A experience. |
| point out the down side to deals. In UPSIDE | | | | In sharing a conference platform with, his |
| magazine, Loren Fox reported some of the | | | | conviction was obvious. He said, "We don't |
| challenges to the marriage. They are: | | | | want to partner, we want to own the whole |
| | | | thing-it's easier that way." |
| · "The holy grail of strategic synergy has | | | | |
| been elusive in the media world." | | | | FASB Accounting Rule Change |
| | | | |
| · "In the offline world, it's notable that | | | | The rules of the game are changing. Some of |
| Time and Warner Brothers have continued to | | | | the accounting benefits of acquisition will |
| run fairly independently despite a decade as | | | | soon disappear. Spending some extra time with |
| Time Warner." | | | | your accounting and legal departments could |
| | | | prove beneficial in the long-term. |
| · "'From any standpoint, this has not been | | | | |
| a success to date,' says Yahoo President and | | | | George Donnelly, in his article in CFO |
| COO Jeff Mallett." | | | | magazine writes, "The current state of |
| | | | accounting rules is clearly a factor in the |
| · "When you buy the company, you get | | | | frenetic acquisition activity at Cisco |
| things you don't need." | | | | Systems and Lucent Technologies Inc. Like |
| | | | many high-tech companies, the two giants can |
| · "Warner might make these deals easier, | | | | acquire with little drag on their finances, |
| but it might also bring new risks-even for | | | | because pooling-of-interest accounting |
| AOL, a veteran of 25 acquisitions over the | | | | enables them to avoid onerous goodwill |
| last six years. Employees might flee to pure | | | | charges that otherwise would ravage earnings. |
| dot-com companies, ego clashes could stymie | | | | |
| plans or financial gains may never cover the | | | | But because of the death sentence the |
| large premium paid for Time Warner." | | | | Financial Accounting Standards Board has |
| | | | levied on pooling, companies must use |
| · "You don't need to own everything to do | | | | straight-purchase accounting after January 1, |
| what AOL and Time Warner are doing." | | | | 2001. Then buyers will have to amortize |
| | | | goodwill for no more than 20 years." |
| Warner-Lambert | | | | |
| | | | Consolidations and Rollups |
| Merger mania can make strange bedfellows, let | | | | |
| alone promises unfulfilled. Alliances can | | | | Bill Wade in Industrial Distribution said: |
| lead to mergers. Warner-Lambert is an example | | | | "The basic premise couldn't be any simpler. |
| of all the above. This is corporate soap | | | | Take a highly fragmented industry-like |
| opera at its best. | | | | distribution-facing technological change, |
| | | | customer upheaval or chronic financing |
| · June 16, 1999, Warner-Lambert Company | | | | difficulties. Add in a few well-healed |
| announced that it has signed a letter of | | | | foreign firms or, worse, a couple of |
| intent with Pfizer Inc. to continue and | | | | previously unknown competitors from outside |
| expand its highly successful co-promotion of | | | | the business. Since the industry leaders are |
| the cholesterol-lowering agent Lipitor | | | | probably family-run businesses with limited |
| (atorvastatin calcium). The companies, which | | | | succession strategies, the next step to |
| began co-promoting Lipitor in 1997, will | | | | protect profit and continue growth is clear: |
| continue their collaboration for a total of | | | | consolidate." |
| ten years. Further, with a goal of expanding | | | | |
| their product collaborations, the companies | | | | A consolidation or rollup, as it's frequently |
| plan to explore potential Lipitor line | | | | called, generally occurs when an organization |
| extensions and product combinations and other | | | | or individual with deep pockets sets out to |
| areas of mutual interest. | | | | buy several small companies in a fragmented |
| | | | industry and rein them in under a new or |
| · November 4, 1999, newspapers across | | | | collective pennant. In 1997 the National |
| America report on "one of the biggest mergers | | | | Association of Wholesale-Distributors |
| of any kind, ever." The Wall Street Journal | | | | reported that 42 of the 54 industries they |
| said, "Now, American Home is set to merge | | | | studied had been significantly affected by |
| with Warner-Lambert Co. in a stock deal that | | | | consolidation. Frequently a professional |
| is valued at about $72 billion. It stands as | | | | management and buying strength create |
| the biggest deal in drug-industry history and | | | | economies of scale that allows the |
| one of on the biggest mergers of any kind, | | | | consolidator to pluck the low hanging fruit |
| ever." Also reported, "Warner-Lambert held | | | | in the industry. They will invest |
| talks with Pfizer Inc. at the same time it | | | | significantly in systems to eliminate the |
| was negotiating with American Home." | | | | duplication of effort and inefficiencies that |
| | | | exist within the industry being consolidated. |
| · November 4, 1999, The New York Times | | | | |
| runs a story titled, "Can a Strong-Willed | | | | While some call it smoke and mirrors, many |
| Chief Share Power in a Merger?" The article | | | | consolidators are yielding outstanding |
| lead with, "The planned merger between | | | | results. In 1997, at 39 years old, financial |
| American Home Products and Warner-Lambert | | | | whiz Jonathan Ledecky pulled off a bold deal. |
| once again raises the question of whether | | | | As reported in CFO magazine, He went to the |
| John R. Stafford, American Home's famously | | | | public equity markets and raised half a |
| strong-willed chairman and chief executive, | | | | billion dollars for his company, |
| is capable of sharing and, perhaps more | | | | Consolidation Capital Corp., in a brazen |
| important, letting go of power." | | | | initial public offering. Without revenues, |
| | | | assets, operating history or identity (name |
| · January 13, 2000, Warner-Lambert Company | | | | or industry), he raised the capital in a |
| indicated that, as a result of changing | | | | blind pool on the strength of his reputation |
| events, it is exploring strategic | | | | alone. |
| alternatives, including meeting with Pfizer, | | | | |
| following Pfizer's recent approach. In that | | | | U.S. Office Products (USOP) is the result of |
| regard, Warner-Lambert said that its Board of | | | | 220 acquisitions. Sharp Pencil was one of six |
| Directors has authorized management to enter | | | | privately owned office-supply companies that |
| into discussions with Pfizer to explore a | | | | Ledecky put together. But he didn't stop, |
| potential business combination. The Company | | | | after two years, and 220 acquisitions later, |
| stated that, in light of changing | | | | USOP was a member of the Fortune 500, with |
| circumstances, its Board had concluded that | | | | $3.8 in revenues. "It was crazy," says Donald |
| there is a reasonable likelihood that | | | | Platt, senior vice president and CFO at USOP. |
| Pfizer's previously announced conditional | | | | Platt did rely highly on outside resources, |
| proposal could lead to a transaction, | | | | including a team of lawyers and accountants |
| reasonably capable of being completed, that | | | | to get the job done (the 220 acquisitions). |
| is better financially for Warner-Lambert | | | | "We restricted then to well-managed, |
| shareholders than the proposed merger with | | | | profitable companies. At worst, we would |
| American Home Products. | | | | still be making money," says Platt. |
| | | | |
| Lodewijk J.R. de Vink, chairman, president | | | | H. Wayne Huizenga is the owner of the Florida |
| and chief executive officer of | | | | Marlins baseball team. He is also the king of |
| Warner-Lambert, stated, "It has always been | | | | consolidators. He pioneered his technique by |
| the Board's objective to secure the best | | | | rolling-up trash-truck businesses to create |
| possible transaction for Warner-Lambert | | | | Waste Management Inc., the nation's largest |
| shareholders and we will now pursue | | | | waste company. He went on to create the |
| discussions with Pfizer to determine if a | | | | largest video chain, Blockbuster Video. With |
| combination with them to achieve that goal is | | | | AutoNation, Huizenga, now struggling, is |
| possible." The Company emphasized that there | | | | attacking the retail automobile industry. In |
| can be no assurance that any agreement on a | | | | mid-December 1999 AutoNation had 409 retail |
| transaction with Pfizer, or that any other | | | | franchises but announced the closing of 23 of |
| transaction, will eventuate. | | | | their used-car superstores. |
| | | | |
| · January 24, 2000, in response to | | | | Michael Riley learned about consolidations |
| inquiries, Warner-Lambert Company said that | | | | while serving as personal attorney for |
| it would continue to explore strategic | | | | Huizenga. In July 1999, Riley's company, |
| alternatives, including discussions with | | | | Atlas Recreational Holdings Inc., paid $14 |
| Pfizer. The Company's unwavering goal is to | | | | million to purchase controlling interest in |
| provide the greatest value to Warner-Lambert | | | | the only publicly traded RV dealership chain |
| shareholders. Warner-Lambert officials | | | | in the United States, Holiday RV Superstores |
| emphasized that there can be no assurance | | | | Inc., in Orlando, Florida. Riley's avowed |
| that any transaction will be completed and | | | | intention is to grow the company from $74 in |
| offered no further comment. | | | | annual sales in 1998 to $1 billion by 2003 by |
| | | | acquiring other dealerships. |
| Was American Home Products the bride left at | | | | |
| the altar? The Wall Street Journal didn't | | | | Riley says, "Consolidations really will help. |
| think so, in fact they called American Home | | | | We can bring advantages to sales and service. |
| the Runaway Bride in their November article. | | | | We can make a difference in warranty. There |
| Additionally they listed several companies | | | | is a real value added when you put these |
| that American Home has them selves left at | | | | companies together." |
| the altar. | | | | |
| | | | Same Industry, Different Strategies |
| · Early November 1997, American Home | | | | |
| Products and SmithKline Beecham begin merger | | | | In mid-1997, roll-ups, United Rentals and |
| talks. | | | | NationsRent were formed. They are in a race, |
| | | | but are using different strategies to achieve |
| · January 30, 1999, Talks break off. | | | | their results. After two years of ravenously |
| | | | gobbling up companies, United had 482 |
| · June 1, 1998, American Home and Monsanto | | | | locations while NationsRent had accumulated |
| announce agreement to merge. | | | | only 138 stores. NationsRent has been |
| | | | developing a nationwide identity with stores |
| · October 13, 1998, American Home and | | | | that look-alike and have the same signage and |
| Monsanto cancel plans to merge. | | | | layout. United Rentals presence is virtually |
| | | | unknown since the stores retain their |
| · November 3, 1999, American Home and | | | | previous appearance. |
| Warner-Lambert Co. in talks to merge. | | | | |
| | | | Motivations for Consolidators |
| Acquisitions | | | | |
| | | | There are several good reasons why |
| An acquisition is basically the function of | | | | consolidators attack a particular industry. |
| one company consuming and digesting another. | | | | The following list provides some of the |
| The result is that the acquiring company | | | | rational that assist them in their decision |
| shores up core weaknesses or adds a new | | | | making process. As you look to profit from |
| capability without giving up control, as | | | | the trend, keep these elements in mind as you |
| might occur in a merger. Added capabilities, | | | | make your selection on whom to acquire. |
| rather than synergy is usually the reasoning | | | | |
| behind acquisitions. In this situation, the | | | | · Confidence by the players that they can |
| acquiring company's culture prevails. | | | | capture significant and highly profitable |
| Frequently one company will acquire another | | | | additional market share by implementing the |
| for their intellectual property, their | | | | cutting edge management, procurement, |
| employees or to increase market share. There | | | | distribution and service practices that will |
| are numerous strategies and reasons why one | | | | give them a competitive edge over smaller |
| company acquires another, as you will soon | | | | players. |
| discover. | | | | |
| | | | · Gain national customers through |
| Guardian Protection Services has been | | | | increased capabilities in delivering the |
| acquiring alarm companies within its | | | | highest levels of standardized service and |
| northeast region of operation to supplement | | | | national geographical coverage. |
| its internal growth. Russ Cersosimo, | | | | |
| president says, "This is just another way for | | | | · Larger customers of independent |
| us to satisfy our appetite for growth. Our | | | | distribution channels are seeking broader |
| desire is to expand our opportunities in the | | | | geographic coverage and networks of locations |
| other offices. That is another reason why it | | | | that allow for greater service capabilities, |
| is attractive for us to look to acquire | | | | and the smaller customers want a high level |
| companies, to get their commercial base and | | | | of customer service and response. |
| commercial sales force that is in place in | | | | |
| those offices. We wanted to make sure that we | | | | · Customers' desire for more product |
| can digest the new accounts without putting | | | | sophistication. |
| strain on our paper flow and the systems we | | | | |
| have in place." | | | | · Insurance and financing synergies. |
| | | | |
| Who does R&D acquisitions well? Electronics | | | | Fragmented Industries Are Ripe for |
| Business recently answered, "Cisco Systems | | | | Consolidations and Rollups |
| Inc., San Jose, the networking equipment | | | | |
| company, which boasts many success stories | | | | Some industries that are ready for |
| among its 40 acquisitions of the past six | | | | consolidations or rollup examples include |
| years." None of their acquisitions were in | | | | heavy-duty truck repair, office products, |
| mature markets, rather all were leading edge, | | | | recreational vehicle dealerships, rental |
| allowing Cisco to broaden its product | | | | stores (equipment, tools and party) and |
| offering. Cisco hedges its acquisition bets | | | | distribution. Consolidation does not just |
| through volume. Ammar Hanafi, director of the | | | | happen. It is triggered by shifts in supplier |
| business development group at Cisco says it | | | | and customer expectations. Consolidation in a |
| counts on two out of three acquisitions | | | | supplier base or customer pool often alters |
| succeeding and the remaining third doing just | | | | the economic rational for the structure of an |
| okay. Acquiring people, intellectual | | | | industry. Functional shifts are accompanied |
| properties and specialized skills is | | | | by serious margin shifts among channel |
| important to companies like Cisco. They think | | | | participants. |
| that even if the acquired technology does not | | | | |
| pan out, they have the engineers. Generally, | | | | Take notice of the speed in which an industry |
| any fast growing company like Cisco cannot | | | | can experience consolidation. If you are a |
| hire people fast enough and the acquired | | | | consolidator, pick the low hanging fruit |
| personnel are a boon to the company's | | | | before another beats you to it. If you are |
| progress. Retention of acquired employees is | | | | fighting consolidation, take notice of the |
| at the heart of their acquisition strategy. | | | | state of your industry and make adjustments |
| "If we're going to lose the people who are | | | | (like strategic alliances) to your business |
| important to the success of the target | | | | plan if your industry is highly fragmented. |
| company, we're probably not going to have an | | | | |
| interest," says Cisco controller Dennis | | | | · TruckPro, the $150 million sales |
| Powell. | | | | creation of Haywood and Stephens Investments, |
| | | | was sold in May 1998 to AutoZone, the $3 |
| "Cisco doesn't do big acquisitions, the | | | | billion distribution king of do-it-yourself |
| cultural issues are too huge," Hanafi says. | | | | auto parts. |
| Cisco buys early stage companies with little | | | | |
| or no revenues. While they often have paid | | | | · In June 1998, nine heavy-duty |
| extremely high prices for the acquisition, | | | | distribution companies with volumes of $6 to |
| they seem to do better than most with their | | | | $37 million, simultaneously merged and raised |
| selection. Between 1993 and 1996, Cisco | | | | $46 million from the public for their brand |
| bought cutting edge LAN switching | | | | new $200 million company, TransCom USA. |
| technologies for a total of $666 million in | | | | |
| stock. More than half was spent on Grand | | | | · Brentwood Associates, a venture capital |
| Junction Networks Inc., which developed fast | | | | company, during Spring and Summer1998, |
| Ethernet switchers. At the time of purchase, | | | | created HAD Parts System, Inc. a $145 million |
| it is estimated that Grand Junction's annual | | | | operation, by acquiring three companies in |
| revenues were $30 million. "Today, the four | | | | the Southeast. |
| LAN switching acquisitions account for $5 | | | | |
| billion of Cisco's $12 billion in annual | | | | · In July 1998, Aurora Capital's QDSP |
| revenues." "We acquire companies because we | | | | acquired majority interest in nine heavy-duty |
| believe they will be successful. If we didn't | | | | companies from FleetPride, a $200 million |
| believe in their success, we would not | | | | parts and service operation. |
| acquire them," says Powell. | | | | |
| | | | Stated in Truck Parts & Service, "Here the |
| Little known West Coast Texas Pacific Group | | | | independent suffers a staggering disadvantage |
| (TPG) has been acquiring at a feverish pace. | | | | to roll-ups. Consolidators have access to |
| Their semiconductor and telecom buying spree | | | | large amounts of capital. The independent |
| includes, GT Com in 1995, AT&T Paradyne (from | | | | businessperson, however, must primarily |
| Lucent Technologies Inc.) in 1996, Zilog Inc. | | | | finance his growth by earnings retains from |
| in 1997, Landis & Gyr Communications SA in | | | | current operations. New high efficiency |
| 1998, ON Semiconductor (from Motorola Inc.), | | | | service bays, significant and growing |
| Zhone Technologies Inc., and Advanced TelCom | | | | training expenses, data processing and |
| Group Inc. in 1999. | | | | communications technology all clamor for |
| | | | increased working capital. The large players' |
| TPG banks heavily on intellectual capital. | | | | acquisition cost advantage eventually will |
| Many believe that by being part of TPG, their | | | | win him all the mega-fleet business and the |
| single biggest advantage is access to broad | | | | vast majority of business from mid-sized |
| pool of talented and well-connected people. | | | | fleets. |
| CEOs can take advantage of TPG's contacts in | | | | |
| other industries around the world. "TPG has | | | | Supplementing his parts acquisition cost |
| this ability to build a virtual advisory | | | | advantage, the consolidator will be able to |
| board...that they don't even have to pay | | | | lower many overhead costs through centralized |
| for," says Armando Geday, president and CEO | | | | management and volume discounts...Combined |
| of GlobeSpan Inc. | | | | savings in parts acquisition cost and |
| | | | overhead reduction should easily exceed 4% of |
| Lucent Technologies, Inc. has also been | | | | sales." |
| rampaging through the same market as Cisco. | | | | |
| Lucent's 1999 (January to August) | | | | Some of the indicators that an industry (any |
| acquisitions as listed in CFO magazine | | | | industry) is poised for consolidation are |
| include: | | | | listed below. If you notice your industry has |
| | | | similar issues, it is just a matter of time. |
| · Kenan Systems for $1 billion | | | | Plan now for what is coming. Where do you |
| | | | want to be when the train arrives? |
| · Ascend Communications for $24 billion | | | | |
| | | | · A high degree of fragmentation with |
| · Sybarus for $37 million | | | | numerous smaller companies and few, if any, |
| | | | dominating players. |
| · Enable Semiconductor for $50 million | | | | |
| | | | · A large industry that is stable and |
| · Mosaix for $145 million | | | | growing. |
| | | | |
| · Zetax Tecnologia, $ N/A | | | | · Multiple benefits for economies of |
| | | | scale. |
| · Batik Equipamentos, $ N/A | | | | |
| | | | · Synergies that can be achieved by |
| · Nexabit Networks for $900 million | | | | consolidating companies. |
| | | | |
| · CCOM, Edisin, $ N/A | | | | · Infrequent use of advanced management |
| | | | information systems. |
| · SpecTran for $99 million | | | | |
| | | | · Limited access to public capital markets |
| · International Network Services for $3.7 | | | | and somewhat inefficient capital structures |
| billion. | | | | among companies. |
| | | | |
| An advantage that Lucent has over its | | | | · Lack of opportunities, historically, for |
| competitors is access to its 25,000-employee | | | | owners to liquidate their businesses if they |
| Bell Labs idea factory. As such, they are | | | | wish to leave the industry. |
| more likely to purchase technology rather | | | | |
| than R&D. Still, Lucent continually reviews | | | | Reasons for Business Owners Selling to |
| the comparative advantages of technology and | | | | Consolidators |
| R&D in relationship to its own projects in | | | | |
| reviewing acquisition possibilities. Lucent | | | | The reasons for a business owner to sell his |
| executive vice president and CFO Donald | | | | or her business are as varied as there are |
| Peterson says, "In every space in which we | | | | people. Usually it is not one reason but |
| have acquired, we have had simultaneous | | | | several combined reasons that influence a |
| research projects inside. It makes us | | | | seller's decision. The following list |
| knowledgeable, and lets us have a | | | | provides you with the general areas that |
| build-versus-buy option." | | | | might drive a selling decision: |
| | | | |
| Lucent wants their units as a hole to do well | | | | · First generation owner, without heirs, |
| and if acquisition helps that cause, they | | | | nearing retirement. |
| acquire. Peterson also says, "We view | | | | |
| acquisition as a tool among many that our | | | | · Lack of capital to make necessary |
| business units can use to advance their | | | | technological and capital improvements to |
| business plans. We evaluate acquisitions one | | | | compete, within an industry, and with new |
| by one, in the context of the business | | | | competitors. |
| strategy of the unit." | | | | |
| | | | · Flat growth rate in industry. |
| Tyco International Ltd. is a diversified | | | | |
| global manufacturer and supplier of | | | | · Better profitability as part of a larger |
| industrial products and systems with | | | | organization. |
| leadership positions in each of its four | | | | |
| business segments: Disposable and Specialty | | | | · Centralized buying. |